The 3-step apology that rebuilds trust

Have you ever apologized to someone, meant every word, and still felt like it didn’t land?

Most of us were taught that a good apology comes down to two things: saying “I’m sorry” and meaning it.

And those are important, of course. But it turns out that “I’m sorry” isn’t actually the most important part of an apology.

Not only that, but some of the things we might feel we should say barely matter at all.

So let’s talk about what actually makes an apology work, and how to put one together.

What research says makes an apology work

In a pair of studies involving 755 people, researchers looked at six common elements of apologies:

• Expressing regret
• Explaining what went wrong
• Acknowledging responsibility
• Declaring repentance
• Offering to repair the damage
• Asking for forgiveness

To see which of these mattered most, the study participants read a letter from someone apologizing for a mistake that had caused problems for others.

Different groups of participants read different letters that included anywhere from one to all six of these elements, and rated how effective the letters were at rebuilding their trust in the person.

Unsurprisingly, the most important element was acknowledging responsibility: the person apologizing and clearly stating that what happened was their fault.

But it’s what came in second place that’s important, and maybe surprising to many. It wasn’t expressing regret, asking for forgiveness, or explaining what had happened. It was offering to repair the damage.

In other words, an effective apology isn’t one that’s focused on how sorry we feel about what happened. It’s about taking responsibility for our mistake and doing something to repair or make up for it.

The three-step apology

It doesn’t hurt to include several of the elements above. But in my years helping people improve their communication and connections with others, I’ve found that simple is often better.

So my rule of thumb for a good apology focuses on those two most important elements—and adds a third one that, in my experience, helps reinforce the first two.

1. Take responsibility for your mistake.

No excuses, no “I’m sorry you feel that way,” no shifting part of the blame onto the other person. Just own what you did.

2. Tell them what you plan to do to make things up to them (or ask them what you can do, if you don’t know).

Sometimes the right way to make amends is obvious. Other times it isn’t, and in those situations simply asking “What can I do to make this right?”—and being ready to act on the answer you get—shows that you’re willing to put in the effort.

3. Tell them how you plan to minimize or eliminate the chance that it will happen again.

This step shows that you’re not just owning the past and making things right in the present, but also using what you’ve learned to strengthen the relationship in the future.

Actions speak louder than promises

All that said, if you don’t follow through on what you say in steps two and three, your apology will end up feeling like nothing but an empty promise, and damage trust in the long run.

In fact, whenever possible, the very best way to do steps two and three is to share specific actions you’ve already taken or are starting to take.

“I’ve already started to …” will always beat “I plan on …” But, of course, if you haven’t had time to make any changes yet, a promise that you follow through on will do.

And this isn’t just common sense (or, I’m sure, something you’ve experienced yourself with people who didn’t keep their word). Research on trust backs it up, too.

In one study, 262 people played a repeated money game with a partner who started out by betraying their trust, and then began behaving fairly.

When the partner promised to change, it helped trust recover faster at first. But in the long run, people who saw the same consistent, trustworthy behavior trusted their partner just as much whether a promise had been made or not.

In other words, promises can open the door, but actions are what rebuild trust.

And that’s exactly why "I’ve already started doing X" tends to land so much better than "I’ll try to do better." The first is something they can see and check. The second is a hope.

Your exercise

Think of a situation—recent or not—where you owe someone an apology, or where your apology didn’t quite land. Then grab a piece of paper and write down:

1. What you’re responsible for, in one or two plain sentences, without excuses.
2. What you could do to make it up to them—or the question you’ll ask them if you’re not sure.
3. One specific action you’ve already taken, or can start taking today, to keep it from happening again.

Is there an apology you’ve been putting off? Maybe this is the week to make it.

PS: If you’re dealing with a small slip in an important conversation rather than a real mistake or offense, take a look at this article of mine to see how to best recover from it.

All the best,
TJ

💻 Learn more: Check out my LinkedIn Learning courses about communication, confidence, and self-esteem.

🤝 Collaborate: Interested in having me give a talk or facilitate a workshop for your people? Message me or reach out via my website.

👀 Connect with me: I post most on my LinkedIn profile and in my Facebook group, but I also share my videos on Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok.